If you loved the atmosphere and the magic
The Night Circus
Erin Morgenstern
Why Matchbook recommends it: A mysterious circus that opens only at night hosts a magical duel between two young illusionists who fall in love.
What to read next
The Invisible Life of Addie LaRue follows a young woman in 1714 France who makes a bargain with a dark god to live forever — at the price of being forgotten by everyone she meets — until, 300 years later in New York, someone remembers her. Readers searching for books like The Invisible Life of Addie LaRue want immortality and bargains with darkness, romance stretched across centuries, art and memory as themes, and atmospheric, bittersweet storytelling.
If you loved the atmosphere and the magic
Erin Morgenstern
Why Matchbook recommends it: A mysterious circus that opens only at night hosts a magical duel between two young illusionists who fall in love.
If you loved love out of step with time
Audrey Niffenegger
Why Matchbook recommends it: A librarian involuntarily travels through time, and his wife's life is shaped by his absences.
If you loved a bargain for eternal life
Oscar Wilde
Why Matchbook recommends it: A young man stays forever beautiful while his portrait ages — the classic Faustian bargain behind Addie's deal.
If you loved stories about stories
Alix E. Harrow
Why Matchbook recommends it: A girl discovers a book about doors to other worlds and a love that crosses them — lush and romantic.
If you loved an immortal romance
Deborah Harkness
Why Matchbook recommends it: A historian witch and a centuries-old vampire are drawn together over a lost manuscript.
If you loved otherworldly beings in old New York
Helene Wecker
Why Matchbook recommends it: Two magical creatures meet in 1899 Manhattan, each hiding what they are — a slow, beautiful story of belonging.
If you want more V.E. Schwab
V.E. Schwab
Why Matchbook recommends it: Two former friends gain extraordinary abilities and become enemies — Schwab's darker, morally grey side.
The romance? The characters? The setting? The twists? Tell Matchbook what worked for you — and what didn't — and we'll find your next read.